
Executive Salary Benchmarking: What Will It Actually Take to Hire the Right Leader?
14 October 2026
Genevieve Kangurs: From Functional Expertise to Enterprise Leadership
21 October 2026Utility Executive Search Case Study for a Managing Director
Some Managing Director searches begin with an established business and a clearly defined leadership profile, this one was a little different.
Douglas Jackson was appointed to identify a Managing Director for a developing Data, Analytics and Environmental Intelligence business within a major environmental and infrastructure services group, backed by Private Equity Goldman Sachs.
The mandate was not simply to manage an existing division. The successful leader would be expected to help create the next version of it: Bringing together IoT, environmental monitoring, data, software and insight into a more scalable commercial platform, while expanding beyond an established Utility and Infrastructure sector footprint into new markets and international territories.
At the same time, changes elsewhere across the senior leadership team meant the context surrounding the opportunity evolved during the search, initially staring our with NDAs and a high level of confidentiality and as the process progressed increasing the need for extremely close candidate communication, judgement and continued engagement particularly important.
Rather than restricting the search to people already holding an identical Managing Director title in an identical business, we deliberately explored a broader leadership market to understand who had the capability to create what the business needed next.
The process ultimately produced two exceptionally strong final candidates, each offering a different route to value creation, before the preferred individual accepted the Managing Director appointment.
Following the appointment, a senior member of the Private Equity investor team contacted Douglas Jackson separately to comment on the strength of the shortlist, while another investor representative expressed how impressed they had been with the search process.
Search at a Glance
Role: Managing Director – Data & Analytics
Business: Environmental / Infrastructure / Technology /Utilities
Ownership: Private Equity-backed
Investor: Goldman Sachs
Business stage: Developing division / growth platform
Core markets: Water, Utilities, Infrastructure and Environmental Services
Mandate: Growth, transformation, diversification, international expansion and value creation
Outcome: Two particularly strong final candidates; preferred candidate offered and accepted
Investor feedback: Strong positive feedback on both shortlist quality and search process
The Business Context
The wider organisation provides environmental, engineering and infrastructure services to organisations operating critical assets across Utilities, Energy and industrial markets.
Its work spans asset strategy, environmental compliance, preventative maintenance, emergency response and the transition towards cleaner and more sustainable infrastructure.
The group had identified Data and Analytics as an important part of its next phase of growth.
The developing business already brought together environmental monitoring, sensing technology and operational data. The ambition was to evolve that capability further, creating a scalable Data and Environmental Intelligence platform capable of delivering greater value across the wider group and into new markets.
The Managing Director would therefore inherit a business with existing capability and revenue, but also a substantial transformation brief.
The original mandate placed responsibility across P&L performance, diversification, international expansion and value creation through data-led and technology-enabled services.
More Than a Traditional Managing Director Brief
The breadth of the role created an unusual leadership challenge.
The successful individual needed enough commercial and operational credibility to lead a substantial business, while also understanding how technology, data and insight could become a more significant part of the value proposition.
The strategy included moving from a more hardware-centric model towards a platform-led Data and Environmental Intelligence business, integrating IoT, software, analytics and engineering capability into a more unified commercial proposition.
Growth ambitions extended beyond the existing Water market into areas including flood resilience, industrial wastewater, smart cities, energy networks and wider environmental and critical infrastructure.
There was also a clear ambition to create new recurring revenue streams through SaaS, PaaS, subscription and managed-service models, while expanding internationally across North America, the Middle East and Europe.
This was therefore not simply:
Who can run this business?
The more useful question was:
Who can turn this capability into a substantially different business over the next few years?
The Leadership Profile Was Naturally Difficult to Find
On paper, the ideal candidate could have looked exceptionally narrow.
The brief potentially combined:
- MD, CEO or divisional P&L experience
- Utilities or infrastructure credibility
- Water sector understanding
- IoT and sensing technology
- Data Analytics
- software and recurring revenue models
- AI and Machine Learning
- international growth
- regulated markets
- M&A and integration
- investor interaction
- commercial transformation
The original candidate profile reflected much of that breadth. It sought leadership experience across areas including IoT and environmental monitoring, industrial technology, Data Analytics, SaaS/PaaS, Utilities, Water and Infrastructure.
Trying to find somebody whose CV matched every element exactly would have created a very small market.
It could also have meant overlooking leaders capable of solving the actual business problem.
Searching for Capability Rather Than a Perfect CV Match
We therefore widened the lens.
Alongside obvious Managing Directors and CEOs, the research explored senior divisional and commercial leaders whose experience suggested they could step into broader P&L ownership and lead the next phase of the business.
We looked particularly closely at the problems individuals had solved.
Had they transformed a technical business?
Could they move a proposition from products towards software, services or recurring revenue?
Had they created growth across different sectors?
Could they operate credibly with technical teams while remaining commercially focused?
Had they led through ambiguity?
Could they work successfully within an investor-backed environment where the expectation was not simply steady management, but meaningful value creation?
That allowed us to consider individuals who might not initially have described themselves as a like-for-like match for the vacancy, but whose experience potentially aligned very strongly with what the organisation was trying to achieve.
Keeping Candidates Engaged Through a Changing Leadership Context
An additional complication emerged during the search as changes elsewhere across the C-suite altered some of the context surrounding the opportunity and for candidates considering a senior Managing Director appointment, that matters.
They are assessing not just the job description, but who they will work with, the level of sponsorship behind the role, how decisions will be made and whether the organisation genuinely has the appetite to deliver the transformation being discussed.
Some individuals who had initially been interested became more cautious, others who might ordinarily have discounted the opportunity needed more context before they could properly assess it. Rather than allow uncertainty to erode the search, we went back into the market, we re-engaged individuals, we explained what had changed and, importantly, what had not.
We revisited parts of the network to test whether different leadership profiles might now provide stronger solutions and we continued challenging whether the strongest candidate necessarily needed to look exactly like the original specification, that work was particularly important because senior candidates rarely make decisions based solely on the role, they make them based on their confidence in the opportunity.
Two Very Different but Compelling Final Options
The process ultimately produced two particularly strong final individuals.
They did not represent two versions of the same candidate.
Each brought a different combination of experience and therefore offered the organisation a different potential route to achieving its ambitions.
That is often more useful at Managing Director level than presenting several candidates whose backgrounds are almost indistinguishable.
It allows the Board and investor to consider not simply:
Who is strongest?
but:
Which version of leadership best matches the future we are trying to build?
Following final assessment, a preferred candidate emerged and an offer was made and accepted.
Investor Recognition of the Search
The response after the appointment was particularly encouraging.
A senior member of the Private Equity investor team contacted Douglas Jackson separately to say how impressed they had been with the quality of the shortlist.
Another investor representative also commented positively on the quality of the overall search process.
That feedback matters because investor-backed leadership appointments are judged through a different lens.
The question is not simply whether somebody can perform the role.
It is whether the individual can help accelerate the value-creation plan.
What This Search Demonstrates
Executive Search should explore the problem, not simply the title
A like-for-like Managing Director search would have been easier to define.
It would not necessarily have produced the strongest leadership options.
By exploring adjacent profiles and transferable experience, the search uncovered candidates who offered different ways of delivering the required outcome.
Candidate engagement becomes part of the search strategy
When the leadership context changes during an assignment, simply continuing with the original process is not enough.
Candidates need communication and context if they are going to remain confident in the opportunity.
In this assignment, re-engagement was an important part of keeping strong individuals in the process.
Investor-backed businesses need leaders who understand value creation
The role combined growth, P&L ownership, technology, recurring revenue, international expansion and M&A.
That requires a different mindset from simply managing an established division.
Different candidates can create value in different ways
The final decision was strengthened by having two genuinely credible but different leadership options.
That allowed the organisation to consider which route best aligned with its strategic priorities rather than simply comparing very similar CVs.
Market intelligence can change the brief
One of the benefits of Executive Search is the ability to learn from the market while the assignment is underway.
When strong individuals fall outside an initially obvious profile, that is sometimes evidence that the brief should be reconsidered rather than the candidate rejected.
The Leadership Signal
The most important Executive Search assignments rarely finish exactly where they started.
The organisation learns.
The market provides new information.
Leadership circumstances change.
Candidates challenge assumptions.
And the search itself creates a clearer understanding of what the business actually needs.
That was particularly true here.
The original requirement could easily have become a highly restrictive search for an MD who already combined Water, IoT, Data, Analytics, software, international expansion and investor-backed leadership.
Instead, the process focused increasingly on the underlying challenge:
Who has the capability to build and scale the business this organisation is trying to create?
That opened the market without lowering the standard.
And it ultimately produced two highly credible but distinctly different routes to the same strategic objective.
For us, that is one of the clearest differences between Executive Search and simply finding somebody who already has the right job title.
Appointing Leadership Into an Investor-Backed Growth Business?
Douglas Jackson works with investors, Chairs, CEOs and Boards appointing senior leaders across Operations, Managing Director, Transformation, Commercial, Customer, Data and Technology leadership.
Our work combines direct market mapping with continual testing of the brief, helping organisations identify not only who has done the job before, but who has the capability to create the value required next.
Talk to us about your next leadership appointment →




