
Nic Cotman: Inclusive Utilities Leadership, Representation and Giving People a Chance
28 October 2025
From Customer Champion to Commercial Translator: The Next Generation CCO
12 November 2025Sometimes the strongest long-term appointment is not the person who looks most obvious on paper.
More than 16 years ago, Douglas Jackson was asked to find a senior Customer Service leader for Charles Tyrwhitt at an important point in the retailer’s growth.
The brief was unusually specific. The business wanted a UK based leader capable of developing its Customer Service operation for future growth and transformation, while also bringing international capability and German language skills.
That combination significantly narrowed the available market.
Rather than restrict the search further by insisting on somebody from an identical retail background, we looked more broadly at the leadership capability the business would need as it grew. The resulting appointment was Mathis Wagner.
Mathis, Director of Customer Services, 16 years later, remains with Charles Tyrwhitt.
During that time, the business and its Customer operation have grown internationally, adopted new technology and AI-enabled services and achieved repeated national and international recognition for Customer Experience and service excellence.
For us, it is an unusually powerful example of what can happen when Executive Search focuses on future capability rather than simply matching previous job titles and sector experience.
Search at a Glance
Current role: Director of Customer Services
Client: Charles Tyrwhitt
Sector: Retail / Ecommerce
Search challenge: Specialist multilingual leadership requirement
Appointment: Out-of-sector candidate
Tenure: 16+ years
Relationship: Multiple subsequent specialist and senior appointments
The Business Context
At the time of the original search, Charles Tyrwhitt needed a leader capable of taking responsibility for Customer Service across a growing and increasingly international business.
The remit covered a multilingual inbound contact centre, customer returns and administration, UK and German outsourced operations, Resource Planning, Training and Customer Service management.
But the role was not simply about managing the existing operation.
The person appointed would also need to develop the medium and long-term Customer Service strategy, evaluate new technology, build business cases for investment and continuously improve the customer experience.
The brief therefore sat across both operational performance and future transformation.
A Particularly Narrow Talent Market
Several elements made the search difficult.
Charles Tyrwhitt wanted somebody based in the UK who could lead a sophisticated Customer Service operation and understand the commercial requirements of a growing retail organisation.
The role required strong Contact Centre leadership, analytical capability, budget ownership, change experience and enough gravitas to influence across the wider business.
In addition, German language capability was highly desirable because of the growing international nature of the Customer operation.
Requiring all of those elements from within one narrow sector would have reduced the talent pool considerably.
So rather than ask only:
Who already has exactly this job in another retailer?
the search considered:
Who has the capability to build what Charles Tyrwhitt will need next?
That led us outside the obvious sector talent pool.
Hiring for Future Capability
Mathis Wagner brought a different background from the conventional profile the business might initially have expected.
What mattered was the combination of capability he could bring to the role: international perspective, leadership, Customer Service expertise and the ability to develop with a growing organisation.
That distinction became increasingly important as the scope of the Customer function evolved.
The original brief already expected the successful leader to act as a customer champion across the business, improve operational performance, optimise resources, develop technology and build the medium-to-long-term Contact Centre strategy.
Sixteen years later, that long-term potential is much easier to see.
Director of Customer Services through change and international growth
Mathis has remained with Charles Tyrwhitt throughout a period of substantial change and international growth.
He has continually progressed, leading an operation that now serves customers across international markets and continues to evolve its use of Customer Experience technology and automation.
The longevity itself matters. Executive Search is often judged at the point somebody accepts an offer.
The more useful measure is what happens afterwards.
Does the individual grow with the organisation?
Do they remain relevant as the business changes?
Can they build capability around themselves?
Does their appointment continue to create value years later?
In this instance, the answer has been remarkably clear.
Building an Award-Winning Customer Operation
Charles Tyrwhitt’s Customer Service operation has gone on to receive significant external recognition.
In 2025 the business achieved a four-award result at the European Contact Centre & Customer Service Awards:
- Gold – Best Supporting Team
- Gold – Best Customer Experience Redesign
- Silver – Greatest Impact of a Multi-AI Approach
- Bronze – Best Customer Experience
The awards recognised transformation across technology, Customer Experience, AI and change delivery.
The original search was not simply successful because the candidate stayed.
The function itself continued to evolve.
Technology, AI and International Growth
More recently, Charles Tyrwhitt has undertaken another substantial transformation of its Customer Service technology.
The business moved away from legacy systems towards a more integrated omnichannel environment, incorporating automation and AI across the Customer journey.
Published results from that programme include improvements in response times, higher NPS, 24/7 Customer Service and the ability to open additional international markets.
An industry review of the transformation also reported more than 50% webchat automation and the ability to absorb approximately 750,000 additional customers without additional headcount.
That is quite a distance from the operation described in the original job specification.
Yet the same leader remains at the centre of it.
The Value of an Out-of-Sector Appointment
Sector experience can reduce perceived hiring risk. Sometimes it is genuinely essential.
But it can also become an unnecessary constraint.
Had the original search simply reproduced the profile of somebody already performing the same role within another retailer, Charles Tyrwhitt might have overlooked a leader who ultimately proved capable of growing with the business for more than a decade and a half.
The question was not:
Has this person already worked in exactly our environment?
It was:
Does this person have the capability to succeed in the environment we are becoming?
Those are very different hiring questions.
A Long-Term Search Partnership
Our relationship with Charles Tyrwhitt did not end with this appointment.
Douglas Jackson has subsequently worked with the business on a number of additional senior, specialist and skilled appointments as its organisation and Customer operation have developed.
That repeat relationship matters to us.
The strongest evidence of a successful search partnership is not simply completing one assignment. It is being trusted again when the next difficult leadership or specialist requirement emerges.
Mathis has also described Douglas Jackson as remaining front of mind as a thought leader within the market, recognising the professionalism and quality associated with our work.
What This Search Demonstrates
Hire for where the organisation is going
The original role needed to operate the Customer function of the day, but the successful candidate also needed enough range to help build the Customer organisation required tomorrow.
Sector experience should be tested, not automatically required
An out-of-sector appointment can bring different thinking, experience and capability when the underlying leadership requirements transfer successfully.
Narrow briefs require genuine search
Combining UK location, German language capability, senior Customer Service leadership, commercial experience and transformation capability created a naturally limited pool.
That is precisely where direct Executive Search adds value.
Retention is one measure of appointment quality
Sixteen years with the same organisation is unusual at senior level.
More importantly, the role and individual have continued to evolve together.
Successful leaders build capability around themselves
The story is not simply Mathis’s progression.
It includes the Customer Service, Change and CX teams that have developed around the function and the recognition they have subsequently achieved.
The Leadership Signal
Looking back at an appointment 16 years later changes the perspective considerably.
At the time, the challenge was to fill a difficult vacancy.
With hindsight, the more important decision was identifying somebody with enough capability and potential to grow with a business that itself would change dramatically.
That is why we increasingly challenge clients to distinguish between:
the experience somebody needs on day one
and
the capability they will need for what comes next.
The two are not always the same.
And sometimes the candidate who looks less conventional at the beginning becomes the appointment that makes the most sense 16 years later.
Hiring Customer, Operations or Transformation Leadership?
Douglas Jackson works with CEOs and senior leadership teams appointing leaders across Customer, Operations, Transformation, Data, Insight and wider Executive leadership.
Our search approach looks beyond titles and conventional career paths to understand the capability an organisation needs now, and the leadership potential it will need as the business evolves.
Talk to us about your next leadership appointment →
Related Content
Recruiting a Customer Service Director
Recruitment a Chief Customer Officer
Retail, Travel and Logistics Recruitment and Executive Search




