
From Customer Champion to Commercial Translator: The Next Generation CCO
12 November 2025
Lyndon Purnell: CIO Leadership, Cybersecurity and the Rise of Fractional Technology Leadership
17 December 2025The best appointment is not always the candidate who looks most obvious on paper.
More than 12 years ago, Douglas Jackson was asked to appoint a senior Customer Service leader for The Estée Lauder Companies in the UK.
The location of the operation, combined with the level of leadership capability required, created a naturally restricted talent pool.
Rather than focus solely on candidates from luxury beauty or prestige retail, we widened the search to look at leaders whose skills could transfer into a very different environment.
The resulting appointment was Tracy Kellaway.
Tracy joined from Financial Services, a considerable sector move into one of the world’s best-known prestige beauty businesses.
Today, she is Executive Director, Global Consumer Care Operations, having progressed significantly within the organisation during a career with Estée Lauder spanning more than 12 years.
Her journey is a strong example of why Executive Search should not simply replicate somebody else’s CV. Sometimes the better question is whether the individual has the capability to grow with the organisation.
Search at a Glance
Current role: Executive Director, Global Consumer Care Operations
Client: The Estée Lauder Companies
Sector: Prestige Beauty / Consumer
Search challenge: Location-constrained leadership market
Appointment: Out-of-sector candidate from Financial Services
Tenure: 12+ years
Progression: Promoted into global leadership
Relationship: Multiple subsequent assignments and ongoing partnership
The Business Context
The original role required somebody capable of running and improving a sophisticated Customer Service operation while preserving the high-touch experience expected from a prestige brand.
The brief covered operational strategy, capacity planning, technology, quality standards, performance management, budgets, people leadership and continuous improvement.
The successful candidate would also need to help shape Customer Service strategy rather than simply manage day-to-day delivery.
The person specification reflected that breadth.
It called for someone with senior Contact Centre experience, strong commercial and analytical capability, the ability to build teams, influence across the organisation and identify opportunities for process or technical improvement.
The challenge was finding that combination within a relatively narrow geographic market.
Looking Beyond the Obvious Sector
One route would have been to search only within luxury retail or beauty.
That would have reduced the perceived risk.
It would also have reduced an already limited pool.
Instead, we focused on the underlying leadership capabilities required.
Tracy came from Financial Services, which on the surface looked very different from prestige beauty.
But the important capabilities transferred.
She brought experience of complex Customer Service environments, operational discipline, people leadership, performance management and the ability to improve the experience for both customers and colleagues.
The sector was different. The leadership requirement was not.
From UK Customer Service to Global Consumer Care
Tracy’s subsequent progression is what makes the original appointment particularly interesting.
She has remained with The Estée Lauder Companies for more than 12 years and is now Executive Director, Global Consumer Care Operations.
Her remit today is global.
Industry sources describe Tracy as responsible for Global Consumer Care Operations across The Estée Lauder Companies, with a particular focus on digital transformation across both the consumer and agent experience. That progression illustrates something we believe matters when assessing senior appointments.
The most successful leaders do not simply perform the job they were originally hired to do. They develop as the organisation develops. They take on broader responsibility.
And they continue to add value as customer expectations, technology and operating models change.
Building a Globally Recognised Consumer Care Operation
The Estée Lauder Companies operates across more than 150 countries and territories and places significant emphasis on the quality of its Consumer Care.
The Consumer Care operation has also achieved external industry recognition.
In 2023, The Estée Lauder Companies won Gold for Best Use of Data & Insights at the European Contact Centre & Customer Service Awards.
Tracy’s standing within the wider industry has grown alongside her organisational responsibilities.
She now serves as a Head Judge for the UK National Contact Centre Awards, where judges are selected for their depth of Contact Centre and Customer Service experience.
That is a useful measure of how far the original appointment has developed.
The candidate who moved from Financial Services into a very different sector is now helping judge excellence across the wider Customer Service profession.
Why the Out-of-Sector Appointment Worked
Out-of-sector appointments are often treated as inherently more risky.
Sometimes they are.
But risk can also come from hiring somebody whose experience is too narrow or whose success has depended heavily on one particular operating environment.
The more useful assessment is:
Which capabilities are genuinely sector specific, and which capabilities will transfer?
In Tracy’s case, the original role needed someone who could:
- lead people
- improve performance
- operate commercially
- understand Customer Service systems and technology
- build structure and standards
- influence across the organisation
- create a high-touch customer experience
Those requirements were more important than whether the candidate had previously worked for a luxury beauty brand.
The appointment demonstrated the value of separating sector familiarity from leadership capability.
Long-Term Partnership
Our relationship with Tracy and The Estée Lauder Companies has continued well beyond the original appointment.
Over the years, Douglas Jackson has supported the organisation with further specialist and senior recruitment requirements.
Tracy has also experienced Douglas Jackson from both sides of the relationship: first as a candidate and subsequently as a hiring leader.
Her recent feedback captures that particularly well:
“I find them professional, knowledgeable, relevant and generous with their time. They are great partners and I would definitely recommend them.”
She also described Douglas Jackson as being “always there no matter which side of the table I am on.”
That matters to us because long-term search relationships are rarely created by a single transaction.
They are built through consistency, market knowledge and trust over time.
What This Search Demonstrates
Sector experience is not the same as capability
Luxury beauty experience may have looked like the obvious requirement.
It was not necessarily the most important one.
Location constraints make search discipline more important
When geography narrows the market, it becomes even more important to distinguish genuine requirements from unnecessary preferences.
Career progression is one measure of appointment quality
Tracy did not simply stay.
She progressed from a UK Customer Service leadership appointment into a global Executive Director role.
Strong leaders evolve with the operating model
Consumer Care has changed significantly over the last decade through digital channels, data, automation and AI.
The leaders who remain effective are those capable of evolving alongside it.
Successful appointments create long-term relationships
Douglas Jackson has continued to work with The Estée Lauder Companies on additional specialist and senior appointments, while Tracy’s relationship with us has moved from candidate to client and trusted industry contact.
The Leadership Signal
There is a tendency in senior recruitment to reduce risk by making candidate profiles increasingly specific.
Same sector.
Same job title.
Same type of organisation.
Same operating environment.
Sometimes that is appropriate.
But every additional condition also makes the market smaller and can prevent organisations from seeing people with the capability to deliver something different.
Tracy’s appointment is a useful reminder that transferable leadership experience can be more valuable than exact sector replication.
Twelve years later, an out-of-sector candidate from Financial Services is leading Global Consumer Care Operations for one of the world’s most recognised prestige beauty businesses.
That is why we believe Executive Search should assess not only where somebody has been, but how far they are capable of going.
Hiring Global, Consumer, Customer, Operations or Transformation Leadership?
Douglas Jackson works with CEOs and senior leadership teams appointing leaders across Customer, Operations, Transformation, Data, Insight and wider Executive leadership.
Our approach combines direct search, market intelligence and assessment of transferable capability to identify leaders who can succeed not only in the role that exists today, but in the organisation you are building next.
Talk to us about your next leadership appointment →
Related Content
Luxury and Retail Recruitment and Executive Search




